Sibert 2026 Predictions! It’s Nonfiction, Man.
Why should the Newbery and Caldecotts have all the fun?
Yes! This year I thought I’d shake things up a little, give the criteria for the American Library Association’s sole nonfiction award for younger kids a looksee, and determine what books released in 2025 might have a fighting chance.
BUT BEFORE I DO, I think it might behoove me to let you know that on Monday, January 26th at 10 a.m. CT they’ll be announcing all the ALA Youth Media Awards right here in beautiful Chicago, Illinois. And to my infinite joy they’ll also be doing them in person. Wanna come? It’s easy! Just fill out this registration form before January 21st and you can cheer / freeze your face in place alongside me, as the books you love (and the books you are, at times, less enthused about) win great big awards all in one morning! Oh, it’s gonna be a blast. And for those of you playing along at home, you’ll be able to watch them live here.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Okay. Let’s get down to it. With absolutely ZERO experience ever deciding a Sibert Medal or honorees, but with a full-blooded appreciation for informational books for kids in all their glory, here’s what I’m loving right now and what I think has a fightin’ chance.
But before we go any further… let’s talk about the big contentious title that has both the best and worst chance, simultaneously:
Death in the Jungle by Candace Fleming
Anyone watch The Studio? If so, you may understand why I can’t help but see Steve Buscemi when I see this cover.
Now we know that The Sibert is not intended for young adults, because otherwise why would we have the grandiosely named YALSA Award for Excellence in Nonfiction for Young Adults (or YAFEINFYA, pronounced Yah-fine-fuhya, if you’re feeling cheeky)? Clearly that award is for teens and this one is for children, yes? But if the Newbery has taught us anything, it’s that ALSC awards have a pretty generous idea of what constitutes “children”. The Newbery itself technically goes up to the age of 14 (so too, does the Caldecott, if you want to get precise about it). And while you may not see it on the Sibert’s ALSC page, if you take the time to download the Procedural Manual (and I did) you’ll learn that, like the Newbery, this award goes to 14 too. Past Medal Winners have also encompassed a range of ages over the years. All this is to say that you cannot count out Candy. She’s an incredible author, her books defy description time and again, and she’s the wild card in this race. That said, the committee is really going to have to wrestle with whether or not a book in which mass suicide plays a significant role is truly for children or not. Personally, I suspect they’re going to leave it to the YAFEINFYA (for the love of god will someone rich PLEASE sponsor that award and rename it?) to give her her due.
Here’s what I think may have a better chance:
Top Pick for the Sibert Medal
The Black Mambas: The World’s First All-Woman Anti-Poaching Unit by Kelly Crull
Once in a while, the Sibert Medal goes to something truly cool. For example, two years ago it went to The Mona Lisa Vanishes, which was SUCH a satisfying win. That book was a bit older, but looking at past winners, what strikes me is the sheer range of age levels that win this award. It’s really quite heartening. Mambas, to my mind, has a real chance at the big win, in part because it’s a truly nuanced read. It’s about an anti-poaching unit, yet manages to humanize the poachers while ALSO making it clear that they can’t continue to do what they do. One of my favorite quotes from the great Michael Hobbes is, “No one ever made a statue to the guy who said, It’s a little more complicated than that.” Yet truly great children’s nonfiction finds a way to present complications in a kid-friendly, comprehensible way. There’s ample backmatter, the sources are backed up, and is there fake dialogue? Of course not. The sole problem with lifting this book up is that it’s going to make every single kid who reads it want to be on an anti-poaching unit someday. I kid (or do I?).
Top Picks for the Sibert Honors
A Gift of Dust: How Saharan Plumes Feed the Planet by Martha Brockenbrough, ill. Juana Martinez-Neal
You should meet my co-worker Martha Meyer. You think I’m passionate about nonfiction? I ain’t got nothing on her. Martha not only started the Blueberry Award (which she promotes with a single-minded intensity that might just save the planet) but she can also booktalk any title into your hearts and minds in less than a minute. You should hear how she talks about A Gift of Dust. It isn’t just the fact that so few adults are aware of the debt we owe to the Saharan Plumes (though that doesn’t hurt). To my mind, a Sibert winner has to rely on more than just a group of adults murmuring, “Gee, I didn’t know that” when they read a book meant for kids. How does the Sibert’s criteria put it? Ah yes. You need an, “Excellent, engaging, and distinctive use of language”, and an, “Excellent, engaging, and distinctive visual presentation,” as well as a, “Clear, accurate, and stimulating presentation of facts, concepts, and ideas.” Over and over and over this book delivers. The fact that you can also tie it into a greater understanding of the interconnectedness of nature? The icing on the cake.
Malcolm Lives! by Ibram X. Kendi
Having brought up the Candace Fleming book as on the fence, one could very well say the same thing for Kendi’s biography. Upon first glance, I had taken this to be a young reader’s edition of an older title. This is not the case, and the book does an incredible (and beautifully sourced) job of tying in different aspects of Malcolm’s life to American history, specifically Black American history, as well as repercussions today. But, as with Fleming’s title, it’s going to be up to the committee to determine if it falls within the age parameters. I think it does, but there are discussions of rape (nothing explicit, but they’re there) so it’s an interesting debate.
A World Without Summer by Nicholas Day, ill. Yas Imamura
If he’s done it once can he do it again? Nicholas Day has a singular ability to create stirring, incredible nonfiction that just sucks a reader in. More to the point, like Kendi he ties the past to the present (and even the future) with this careful consideration of climate change and all that that entails. Plus it has Frankenstein. I mean… you not gonna give a medal to Frankenstein?
Those are just my thoughts. Feel free to contest or question them. Or better yet, tell me what you think has a definite shot! We won’t know for a couple more weeks, so give us your best arguments!
Filed under: Uncategorized
About Betsy Bird
Betsy Bird is currently the Collection Development Manager of the Evanston Public Library system and a former Materials Specialist for New York Public Library. She has served on Newbery, written for Kirkus, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of EPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on BlueSky at: @fuse8.bsky.social
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
One Star Review, Guess Who? (#239)
I Witnessed: The Great Train Robbery of 1963 | Review
Friday Exercise: Delineation of Setting
From Policy Ask to Public Voice: Five Layers of Writing to Advance School Library Policy
Sunrise on the Reaping Movie Review
Luke Pearson Made a Picture Book!
ADVERTISEMENT



Totally agree on Black Mambas! It should sweep the awards this year!
Thank you, Betsy, for writing about The World Entire, here and in your earlier column. This book is outstanding in every way. I have a question: is it eligible, given that Melissa Castrillón lives and works in the U.K.? I’m not sure.
I would like to make an unrelated point about the book’s subject, the desperate attempt to save Europe’s Jews before the doors were completely closed to emigration. In theory, a book’s subject should not matter. Excellence can be found in books about any topic. In practice, it seems that judges take the subject into consideration. It is certainly true that the disgraceful treatment of immigrants by ICE needs to be constantly brought to our attention. However, books about the Holocaust, or other tragedies in Jewish history, are not only valuable because they shed light on other disasters. (I would recommend reading Dara Horn’s essays about Anne Frank, and Holocaust education.) Two-thirds of Europe’s Jews were murdered. Over 95% of Jews in some Eastern European countries were annihilated. As there are fewer and fewer survivors left to speak out, it is important not to reduce this part of history to a symbol or reminder. I know that you appreciate that fact, and that you often write about Jewish-themed books. Thank you again.
True enough, Emily. Those are excellent points.
And shoot. You’re also correct about Melissa not being eligible. I think I’ll have to excise this book from the posting for both that reason and the others you’ve brought up. Thank you very much for your thoughtful response.
I don’t know if there are any other ALSC awards for which the book would qualify. It has not received enough attention; thank you again.
This is precisely why I keep lobbying for us to rid ourselves of that archaic nationalistic American requirement. So many great books get lost in the shuffle.
Someone else just pointed out that We Carry the Sun is ineligible for the same reason. I did NOT do proper homework on this post, I see.
Teeny question about registration, do you know if there is supposed to be a confirmation sent out when one completes the form? I filled it out, but nothing appeared in my inbox.
I did it 2 weeks ago but I’m 99% certain I didn’t get a confirmation in any way. I think you’re okay.
Another data point–I haven’t gotten anything either.
I would love to see A WORLD WITHOUT SUMMER receive recognition, and A GIFT OF DUST as well. I think HURRICANE by Jason Chin could be in the mix, too: it focused on a particular storm and a particular community as an example of how hurricanes form, how people prepare for them (and study and monitor them – I did not know it was a job to fly in and out of them the whole time they’re happening!), and how disaster recovery takes place after a storm has swept through. As destructive storms become more common, this is both a timeless and timely title.
Good point on the Chin!
Love to see Sibert Award predictions! One of my favorite things about the award is that it encompasses both text and visual elements rather than one (coughNewbery) or the other (coughCaldecott).
Also, I’m with you on wishing we could drop the US citizen/resident requirements. So much nonfiction addresses topics that are global (or are set outside the US), and it seems a shame they can’t be contenders.
As a rhino guy, I’ve been waiting for a Black Mamba book for years! I was thrilled to see it on 31 Days/31 Lists and I can’t wait to read it.
While I think Death in the Jungle is too sophisticated for even the upper end of the Sibert’s target audience, it would be a perfect candidate for the Printz. It’s exceptionally well crafted. Candy is a genius.
Other books I hope will get some Sibert love:
Alberto Salas Plays Paka Paka con la Papa: Join the Quest with Peru’s Famed Scientist and Potato Expert by Sara Andrea Fajardo and Juana Martinez-Neal
The joy of scientific discovery conveyed in this book makes it my top pick.
The History of We by Nikkolas Smith
The Keeper of Stories by Caroline Kusin Pritchard and Selina Alko
In the World of Whales by Michelle Cusolito and Jessica Lanan
Make a Pretty Sound: A Story of Ella Jenkins—the First Lady of Music by Traci N. Todd and Eleanor Davis
Tomatoes in Trial: The Fruit Vs. Vegetable Showdown by Lindsay H. Metcalf and Edwin Fotheringham
This book is just SO much fun.
Zero: The Number that Almost Wasn’t by Sarah Albee and Chris Hsu
Go Tell It: How James Baldwin Became a Writer by Quartez Harris and Gordon C. James
Toes, Teeth, and Tentacles: A Curious Counting Book by Steve Jenkins and Robin Page
Marvelous suggestions. ALBERTO SALAS is a true gem.
Thank you, Betsy, for highlighting nonfiction!
Ty, Betsy, for bringing attention to the Sibert and nonfiction! I am particularly drawn to Go Tell It: How James Baldwin Became a Writer by Quartez Harris and Gordon C. James. It is a masterful biography that introduces younger readers to James Baldwin. It’s an homage to reading and writing with art and words work together magically.
I really appreciated the refrain of “refuge” in art, words, and music. I love that Harlem is a character in this book! Yes, it touches on police brutality, abusive fathers, parental reaction to queer child – tough topics, but they are presented in a balanced way with beautiful storytelling. This biography could be used with a myriad of age groups – elementary, middle grade and even high school kids!
Oh yes!! I adored GO TELL IT!
I love that you’re highlighting NF! Back when I was still a high school media specialist — a few years ago — my students loved reading NF picture books, especially our debate team and kids working on research projects. I even got teachers on board — finding books for them that aligned with the curriculum and having them open their lessons with a book. Please keep spotlighting these works. <3
This is a fantastic list for this year!
Thank you for spotlighting these great nonfiction titles and sparking the comments on even more. Inspiring!
Yes! Black Mambas was a runaway hit in 5th grade this year. We’re voting on our Sibert Smackdown next week, but I’m predicting their go with that, In the World of Whales, and Zero. So many good choices this year!
I would be SO happy if Zero got some love!
This is so fun! I have a question: do you think more poetic/informational books like Leslie Barnard Booth’s I AM WE: HOW CROWS COME TOGETHER TO SURVIVE could ever become more competitive for this award? It was my fave of the year!
I adore that book, but since it’s this amalgamation of fiction and nonfiction, I’m not sure it would have a chance. Alas, it’s not eligible anyway since Alexandra Finkeldey is Canadian.
Oh, yay! A Sibert prediction post. I have long been a big fan of Melissa Stewart’s Sibert Smackdown. I’m so glad to see you getting into the action!
Thanks for posting about your Sibert predictions! Go nonfiction!
Some nonfiction love, hooray! I would love to see The Spider Lady: Nan Songer and Her Arachnid World War II Army by Penny Parker Clostermann win the Sibert.
The storyline blows my mind. First of all, who knew that spider silk was used to create the cross hairs in sights. Second of all, you can collect a spider’s silk? What?? And finally, the process of scientific investigation is on full display along with quotes that showcase the author’s deep research. Penny wove a winner.
Thanks for sharing! I’ve added to my reading list.
Thanks for sharing! This is so helpful.
Death in the Jungle was excellent. And there was so much great nonfiction this year. I’m glad I’m not one of the people who has to choose!