The Scourge of Upside Down Knitting Needles 2026: The Petty Petty Series RETURNS Once More!!
It’s heeeeere!
Oh, sweet sweet bitter post. Balm to my soul. You know, in my early snarky days I took great delight in tearing perfectly nice and innocent books asunder. Those days are gone… until I do this post once more.
Yes! It’s the return of the pettiest post of the year! You see, my dear friends, knitting is a controversial subject. Why, just this year even Hank Green got in trouble for a video that discussed the act of knitting. For me, though, knitting presents a bit of a conundrum. On the one hand, I like to see it represented in picture books. On the other hand, some days it feels like half the illustrators out there appear to be incapable of understanding how to draw knitting needles! Here’s a quick and easy guide:
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Correct Way to Hold Knitting Needles:
Incorrect Way to Hold Knitting Needles: ANY OTHER WAY
Now children’s book illustrators like to put knitting into their pages. And they really really like to show the ends of the knitting needles standing straight up like they’re an old-fashioned pair of antennae on a television circa 1975. This, my friends, is misinformation and laziness and it simply will not stand. As such, every year, I compile every instance of knitting I found in a book. And folks, I read a lot of books for kids.
We’re going to look through the ones who did it right and the ones who did it poorly. Then we are going to assess how well we did. Are more people catching on and illustrating knitting correctly, or are we worse off than before? I’ll show you my results (just as I did in 2025, 2024, 2023 and 2022).
Oh. And let us dispense with the usual objections to this post right off the bat:
Question: Has anyone ever knit with the bottoms of the needles pointed sky high? Answer: Yes, but it literally makes no sense. Why fight gravity? And, quite frankly, even if your Scottish great-grandmother from 1910 knit this way, that’s no reason why anyone should make knitting needles look like that in a contemporary picture book.
Question: Does it matter? Illustrators know that it just looks better to have them pointed up. Shouldn’t simple visual aesthetics get a hand in this? Answer: No. We live in an era of misinformation. I will not compromise my morals just because an illustrator was incapable of doing a simple Google search on “knitting”.
Question: Why are you like this? Answer: On with the show!!!
In no particular order…
The Fountain by Lisa Lofredo
We’re starting off with a heartbreaker. Lofredo’s an Italian illustrator currently living in Amsterdam. The Fountain, meanwhile, is this truly delightful story about a generous fountain that gives random gifts to a town’s citizens. And here you’ve a bat knitting… with the knitting needles going in completely the wrong way. I’ve never really been able to determine if European illustrators are more prone to this sin than Americans. I guess we’ll find out today…
The Mueganos by Jacque Jours
Ahh. That’s better. Okay, so it’s a little difficult to tell from this angle, but as you can see, in the upper left-hand corner you’ve two paws knitting. The needles are pointing downward. More importantly, Jours seems to understand the rudimentary fundamentals of knitting and how it works. She didn’t have to show stitches to show that she knew how to depict the craft. Well played.
The Smushkins: Colors by Claudia Rueda
Very nice. And in a board book no less. Notice how even when the needles is parallel to the floor, you can see the stitches holding it up. This is how it’s done, people.
A Teeny Tiny Baby by Amy Schwartz
I’m counting reissues today, by the way. Now in her defense, when Schwartz originally released this book in 1994 illustrators had been depicting knitting poorly for years. You ever see how Dr. Seuss or P.D. Eastman showed knitting? Deplorable. So Schwartz hadn’t yet entered an era where folks had a say in protesting. Still rankles, though.
Zenguin by Danna Smith, ill. Sydney Hanson
Full credit to Ms. Yingling for pointing this one out to me. Pip here isn’t knitting per se, but you can see how beautifully the stitches are cast onto those needles. This image suggests that Hanson knew how to draw the act. A more sophisticated example of correct knitting needle placement. Nicely done.
Jacomini by Rebecca Dautremer
We talk a lot about needle placement and not nearly enough about stitches. Feast your eyes on the big beautiful ones in this delicate French board book import. Full honors all around.
Ramadan for Everyone: A Muslim Community Story by Aya Khalil, ill. Rashin Kheiriyeh
FULL honors here. Not only are the knitting needles perfectly aligned but you’re showing women and men knitting side-by-side? Man, if I was giving out awards, this would certainly be at least a finalist. Sure, it’s a little unclear how exactly needle #1 is interacting with needle #2, but who cares? Knitting parity! Huzzah!
Whale, That Was Unexpected by Casey Lyall, ill. Kathryn Durst
*sigh* Whale, that was to be expected. Why is it that the funny charming books so consistently get this wrong? Then again, I’m kind of mesmerized now, trying to figure out how Maude here is managing to levitate the two needles between her hands. This looks less like knitting and more like a fuzzy red slug sidling up for a cuddle.
Korobá: The Case of the Missing Kolo by Àlàbá Ònájìn
Aside from being one of my absolute favorite graphic novels of the year, the knitting in this mystery GN is rendered nicely. We’re not seeing any cast on stiches but hey! At least the needle ends are pointed in the right way!
The Sweater: A Story of Community by Larissa Theule, ill. Teagan White
Bravo, Teagan White. When your book is called “The Sweater” and a plot point hinges on the heroine’s ability to knit, it behooves you to get that process down. Look at those nice knitting needles. Very well done here.
Otherwise Known as Judy the Great: A Poetic Ode to Judy Blume, ill. Selina Alko
Okay. So this one’s difficult to ascertain. There are two needles and each of these women are kind of holding them. Between the V-sign there’s a piece of yarn. I think this is supposed to be knitting and not some other craft, but I’m afraid we’re going to have to point out that the ends of the needles are pointing straight up here. That’s disappointing.
Agents of S.U.I.T.: Sew Much Trouble by John Patrick Green with Christopher Hastings and Pat Lewis
Well, color me shocked. One would assume that when a popular graphic novel series decided to show an octopus 9or possibly a squid) knitting on the cover that those needles would be inaccurate as the day is long. But while it is a little unclear exactly why the parachute being knit isn’t really attached to the needles in question, there’s no denying that their ends? They are correctly positioned. This one counts as correct!
Little Bunny’s To-Do List by
Another credit to Ms. Yingling for locating this one. And, as she points out, it appears that Little Bunny is left-handed. Nothing wrong with that since these needles are nicely placed. Good job here!
To Knit a Ghost by Z.B. Asterplume, ill. Heather Brockman Lee
Every year there’s one book that stands above and rest in terms of not just correct needle placement but an understanding of knitting itself. This year that honor goes to the extraordinary To Knit a Ghost. And when you look at the art, you can see why I took as many pictures of it as I did. Heather Brockman Lee went above and beyond the call of duty, and we salute her!
The River of Caregiving by Jocelyn Chung, ill. Sarah Gonzales
Just admire for a moment the confidence of illustrator Sarah Gonzales. Not only do we get an accurate look of Great Auntie knitting, but then in the same spread you ARE Great Auntie and you’re the one doing the knitting! She even took time to wrap the yarn around the forefinger, as if to say to the reader, “Oh yeah. I’m an old hand at this.” Bold.
Seasons by the Lake: Adventures in Greenland by Naja Lund Aparico, ill. Alex Nees

Well… huh. What do y’all make of this? I’m inclined to think it’s correct. At first it appears that the knitting needle ends are pointed up, but if you look closely, the way her hands are positioned, I actually think that those are the tips of the needles instead and not the ends. I do believe that this is correct needle placement. Do you concur?
Rebecca by Kate Beaton, ill. Sydney Smith
Is knitting?
Is not knitting?
Is unclear. Sydney Smith is a genius and this book made me cry multiple times in airports, but I’m not quite certain what we’re seeing here. Undecided.
Cabin Head and Tree Head: Feeling Good by Scott Campbell
That’s Cabin Head, for you. Strong AND sensitive. And well played on the knitting needle placement, Scott Campbell. Just like that, folks. Just like that.
Sugar Glider Lights a Way by Maya Tatsukawa
These images from inside the book are a bit small and dark but I assure you that all the animals featured here knitting in the trees know which way their needles should point. Even the bat hanging upside down has it well in hand.
Acacia: A Rapunzel Tale by JaNay Brown-Wood, ill. John Joven
While I’ll admit that with the way her knitting is hanging here, it looks more like Acacia is lace making than knitting. But those needles are correctly positioned in her hands, so as far as I’m concerned that is a WIN for Team Ends Down.
The Very Unusual Pumpkin by Marilyn Singer, ill. Maya Shleifer
YUS!! Correct needle ends AND you can even see how the knitting is falling between them. Maya Shleifer knows from which she illustrates. This is one of the best examples I’ve seen all day. Brava.
Kingdom Unraveled by Mariana DiMercurio
Oof. A heartbreaker. You know, for a book with a subtitle like “A closely knit graphic adventure”, you’d expect a little more knitting in this book in general. But when you do get knitting, it looks like this. Needles waving their little butts in the air like the illustrator just didn’t care. A lost opportunity.
Together for Mama: A Story of Hope and Healing by Pooja Makhijani, ill. Nadia Alam
Noice! Needles down. This book does it right. You know, I should start keeping track of how many illustrators do or do not include an attached ball of yarn to their knitting. I’m beginning to wonder if not everyone things to add it.
Henri and the Secret Letters by Fanny Ducasse
Ah, alas. And I had such high hopes for this one. Perhaps badgers just aren’t good at fiber arts. Whenever I see a character producing something from this position, I can’t help but imagine that they’re just randomly stabbing that sock into existence.
Sage and the Snowshoe Express by Louise Bradford, ill. Maya McKibbin
Falls squarely into the category of I’m-not-sure-how-that-hat/mitten-got-there-but-at-least-the-needles-are-right!
Frog Face by Blythe Russo
Hmm. I’m going to label this one inconclusive. Yes, the needle (singular) is pointed down, and that’s great. But where’s the other needle? Should we say that this is crochet instead? It’s not really answering the question one way or another. I declare this one unclear.
One Red Thread by Lindsay Ward
Ahhh. Here we go. Not only do we have great needles bu the mixed media allows you to see what it is that’s being knit. Look at those stitches! This is Class A work.
The Weather Shop by Thomas Lee, translated by Deborah Smith
Adorable Korean import. Utterly baffling approximation of not just knitting but MY preferred craft, spinning! I think they’re creating something magical here, but don’t you still need wool to spin?? Artists adore wrapping the yarn around the wheel itself, but in this case, Lee might be modeling this after a Korean spinning wheel. Looks like it could be the same, yes?
Whatever the case, I don’t care how much magic you have. Stabbing wool repeatedly doesn’t make scarves.
Otto’s Sweater by Sadhbh Devlin, ill. Roisiin Hahessy
Oh dear. This is a classic example of the needles having very little to do with whatever is happened beneath them. They’re just pointed way up to the sky and there’s nothing to be done about it.
Magic Elizabeth by Norma Kassirer, ill. Mark Richardson
The rare middle grade novel (but fully illustrated). This title was reprinted this year after its initial run in 1966. We featured a previous book by Norma and Mark in 2024 called The Knitting Witch. That book played with knitting needles and their positions in a cheeky way. This book? Totally doing it straight. Apparently Mark wished to atone for his witch’s “vile appurtenances” being in “antennae mode.” He has been redeemed.
And now, as is our custom, an ode to those crafts that may or may not be crochet:
Good Families Don’t by Robert Munsch, ill. Joy Ang
I’m willing to take bets on this one that it really is crochet. Mom seems to be holding just a single needle, right? This book is a reprint of an older Munsch release, now with new art, but there’s nothing in the text to explain what Mom might be doing here. My vote is crochet. Who’s with me?
The Big Once-a-Year Broussard-Bouchard Family Reunion by Karen English, ill. Annalise Barber-Opp
Okay. Help me out crafters. Again, I’m betting that this is crochet since there only seems to be one needle and it has a small hook at the end. Justified? Whatever it is, this woman looks like she’s concentrating really hard, and yet she hasn’t even really started.
Miles Ahead by Minh Le, ill. Lynnor Bontigao
If you’re beginning to suspect that I just move the most unclear images into the “crochet” section, you’re not wrong. This particular image is a stumper. But generally speaking, if I can only make out one needle, I’m going to put it in the crochet slot. You may contest my assertion.
Harlow the Highland Cow Doesn’t Know How to Moo by Brooke Hartman, ill. Nancy Leschnikoff
A book notable for being one of the very very few to actually specify that crocheting is going on! Most books (as you can see) leave everything very loosey goosey. Not Harlow.
And that’s that!
Okay, it’s time for the count. Out of the thirty books that were definitely featuring knitting, how many held the needles correctly? The results:
Held Knitting Needles Correctly: 21
Held Knitting Needles Incorrectly: 8
Not Entirely Certain What Was Going On There: 1
And there you have it!! Overall, correct knitting needle placement still pulled ahead!
If there are any 2026 publications for kids that you think that I’ve missed, be sure to let me know! And a big thanks to all the illustrators out there for being such good sports about this silly silly post.
Filed under: Uncategorized
About Betsy Bird
Betsy Bird is currently the Collection Development Manager of the Evanston Public Library system and a former Materials Specialist for New York Public Library. She has served on Newbery, written for Kirkus, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of EPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on BlueSky at: @fuse8.bsky.social
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
Endangered Series #32: Bone
This Week’s Comics | Wild Paws
The Early NOTHING: and why that’s so!
From Policy Ask to Public Voice: Five Layers of Writing to Advance School Library Policy
Writing a Playbook for Justice, a Playbook for Hope, a guest post by Lesley Younge
Luke Pearson Made a Picture Book!
ADVERTISEMENT


