Fuse 8 n’ Kate: The Mitten by Jan Brett

Since the entire premise of my podcast with my sister is to take well-known books and determine whether or not they continue to deserve their “classic” status, it probably behooves me to do a couple books everyone has actually heard of. And since the last book I did was, at best, obscure and, at worst, completely forgotten, I figured today we should go all in and do something out-and-out famous. To my surprise, we’ve never tackled a Jan Brett book before. That said, I have to admit that it’s possible that Kate and I are not the world’s most impartial critics. You see, our mother instilled in us an appreciation for fiber arts. and can you think of a single illustrator who has ever depicted the knitted stitch better than Ms. Brett? We consider the woman’s best-known book and how it has held up over all this time as well as the timeliness of doing a Ukrainian folktale in this day and age.
Listen to the whole show here on Soundcloud or download it through iTunes, Stitcher, Spotify, Google Play, PlayerFM, or your preferred method of podcast selection.
Show Notes:
Rant Alert: We don’t bring this up, but after the recording I decided to look into what exactly won Caldecotts in 1990 (the year this could have gotten something). The winner that year? Lon Po Po, and I can’t argue there. In fact most of the Honors were great and include books we’ve featured on the podcast (Hershel and the Hanukkah Goblins). So here’s my controversial call. I would have been happy to lose either Bill Peet by Bill Peet or Lois Ehlert’s Color Zoo (really, judges?) in favor of THIS book getting an Honor instead. And I stand by that statement. Jan Brett has NEVER won a Caldecott and, by this point, she probably never will. Somebody look me in the eye and tell me friggin’ Color Zoo was better than this. My theory is that the committee determined that the realism of this book was too similar to Trina Schart Hyman’s and Jerry Pinkney’s (who won an Honor for The Talking Eggs that year) books and they wanted to have a variety of styles. Still doesn’t justify the snub.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
I do mention at one point during the show that this isn’t the only picture book version of the mitten out there. Traditionalists may enjoy this previous title by Alvin Tresselt and Yaroslava:

Or this Jim Aylesworth/Barbara McClintock beauty:

The first indication that this book honors the fiber arts? Behold! A spinning wheel. Is accurately rendered? Ah… kinda? I mean, she’s sort of purposefully hiding a key part of it, but we’ll give her a pass. It’s not Paul Zelinsky level good, but it’s up there.

In the course of my research for this podcast I read a fair number of interviews with Jan Brett about her work on The Mitten. My favorite? This one with TeachingBooks.net. In it, Jan really leans into the research she did for the title, as well as the Ukrainian ex-patriots who suggested, “I make Nicki’s clothes too big for him because his family would have made them by hand and passed them down from father or older brother. He’d wear a belt to make his jacket fit closer around his tummy. The boots, too, might be a little big. He might stuff some newspaper in them or wear an extra pair of socks to make them fit.” In that light, this book actually makes so much more sense.

A couple things to point out about this next image. First off, 100 points to Jan Bret for the correct positioning of knitting needles in this image (a problem some of you may recall I have with a LOT of picture books in a given year). Second, sometimes grandmothers will complain to me about how they’re depicted in children’s literature. Too often they’re seen as decrepit old nannies, barely toddling along on their last legs. This grandma? First off, she’s living just with her grandson here, and I don’t think anyone’s visiting her today, but LOOK at her! She’s vibrant. She’s energetic. Her hair is incredibly perfect (to say nothing of her clothing and accessories). I should look so good on my normal days at work! This is something to aspire to, people. This is class.

Choose to agree or disagree with me that this should have won a Caldecott something, but the fact that the hedgehog’s prickles are visible through the incredibly accurate stitches in this image . . . right there, the book just blows me away.

It’s a little difficult to tell, because the fox has just stuck its head in the mitten, but that nose on the far right? I think it’s pretty clear that that has to belong to the badger that arrived a page before. Case closed.

And the winner of the silent final spread in a picture book goes to . . .

Betsy Recommends: Triangle of Sadness
Kate Recommends: Playing a game of D&D (and the podcast Tales from the Stinky Dragon).
Filed under: Fuse 8 n' Kate

About Betsy Bird
Betsy Bird is currently the Collection Development Manager of the Evanston Public Library system and a former Materials Specialist for New York Public Library. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of EPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
How to Do Just About Everything in 2025
How to Draw a Secret | This Week’s Comics
Goodbye for now
When Book Bans are a Form of Discrimination, What is the Path to Justice?
Penguin Random House Showcase
ADVERTISEMENT
I haven’t listened to your the episode yet, so I don’t know what you’ll be saying, but I definitely agree with you about Jan Brett deserving a Caldecott something! My daughter and I love her books. We pour over every page, finding new details with each reading. Every one of her images just seems so intentional. And she’s got one of the best and most useful author websites I’ve found! I’m looking forward to listening to what you and Kate have to say!
I recently did a Mock Caldecott lesson with my students. We reviewed over 150 books and then voted by 5 qualifications.
My students came to the conclusion that adults choosing books for children’s book awards have an agenda.
Best that they learn this now. It takes many an adult years and years to come to this difficult truth.
Brett’s detail is always spectacular and I really appreciate the information about her research process regarding the clothing. Right before the holidays we have first graders compare the different versions of “The Mitten” as well as “One Dog Canoe” by Mary Casanova.
Here’s my controversial comment. I think the Tresselt version is much better written. I also prefer the Aylesworth. While I agree Jan Brett’s images are stunning, I find the story so much more engaging in the other two. Of course having grown up with the tresselt (It was gifted to me at around the age of one by an amazing librarian) nothing ever quite lived up to those words and images. I do find it surprising Brett has never won a Caldecott, but this would not have been my choice of a winner. I think my favorite of hers is Honey…Honey…Lion.