Review of the Day: The Swing by Robert Louis Stevenson
There comes a moment in a new parent’s life when they realize that they have become their own parents. It’s different for everyone. For some folks it won’t happen until they’re berating their teenagers, conjuring up terms and threats from their own youth that they swore they’d never use. For others, it happens at practically the moment after conception. And for me, it happened when I read my one-year-old daughter Julie Morstad’s simply irresistible adaptation of Robert Louis Stevenson’s classic poem The Swing. As I read the book aloud I realized that I had heard this poem myself as a child. I could even recall the images that accompanied it, filled with sickly sweet children with cheeks so large they’d make the Campbell Soup kids seem wan in comparison. And when later I heard my own mother recite this poem I was amazed to discover that my reading, which I’d done several time for my own daughter, contained the exact same cadences and turns of phrase as my mother’s rendition. The difference for my daughter will be the fact that while the art accompanying my The Swing was tepid, the images that appear in Julie Morstad’s gorgeous little board book are utterly lovely creations. For all those parents desperate to introduce their toddlers to poetry, or just folks who want to read their kids something beautiful for once, here is the answer to your prayers.
“How do you like to go up in a swing / Up in the air so blue?” I should think you’d like it very much if you were one of the children in Julie Morstad’s clever little book. Adapting Robert Louis Stevenson’s words, Ms. Morstad fills her pages with kids on their way up, their way down, and everywhere in-between. They glide under cherry blossoms, observe the even rows of plants and vegetables, and swing like superheroes on their bellies. The result is a haunting but thoroughly enjoyable update to a poem that feels as fresh and fun as it was the day it was first published in the late 1800s.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Etsy has been a simultaneous boon and problem for the children’s picture book world. On the one hand, there is no better place for editors to find up and coming artists. Never before has a public forum of this scope yielded such rich artistic talent. On the other hand, there is a kind of Etsy “look” that typifies the people found there. It’s what allows reviewers like myself to view certain kinds of children’s books and sniff “Etsy” when we want to put them down. Now at a first glance Morstad’s work on The Swing might strike you as falling in the Etsy vein. An unfair assumption since as far as I can tell Ms. Morstad sells her art herself and not through Etsy. More to the point, this book is better than that. Granted I wouldn’t mind taking some of the images found in the book and framing them on my wall (particularly that cover image with the black background and white haired girl swinging through a field of vibrant blossoms). But there’s a quality to Ms. Morstad’s art that feels more than merely trendy. There’s a lot of beauty here, and it ties in directly to the subject matter.
Books about swinging for children are the one-act plays of children’s literature. Tied entirely to a single place where the vertical is exchanged for the horizontal, it’s hard to make a narrative around swinging. Indeed that’s probably why books like Higher Higher by Leslie Patricelli have been for the very young set while Tricia Tusa’s Follow Me has looked at other aspects of swinging entirely (colors, etc.). The best attempt at the genre was probably Joe Cepeda’s The Swing which had a kind of Calvin & Hobbes type of plot. Morstad’s adaptation of Stevenson’s poem is smart because rather than show a single kid just going up and down and down and up she shows a wide range of children swinging in all kinds of different settings.
Looking at the book itself I was impressed by the design of the thing. It fools you for the first few pages, allowing you to think that you’re reading yet another book where the text is on one page and the images on the other. Yet when you reach the lines “Oh, I do think it the pleasantest thing / Ever a child can do!” the words curve and dive around two tow-headed children, swinging against a verdant green background. Each image carries with it a distinctive mood and feel. There’s one scene of a child swinging over “River and trees and cattle and all” while a midday sun sinks red towards the horizon. Of course I’ve already mentioned my favorite image in the book, which is the one on the cover. Happily Ms. Morstad comes full circle with that girl. She appears at first on the cover, and then once again at the end of the book with the final lines “Up in the air and down!” There you see her white hair, little pink shoes, and jet black background in place. This time, however, her swinging has definitely slowed down and she regards the reader with a small smile and a sense of complacency you can’t help but envy. Plus the fluorescent flowers are cool. Like those.
I am pleased to report that while I dislike it when folks use their own children as control groups, determining whether or not a book works, in this particular case I feel no guilt in reporting that my one-year-old is a fan. I’m not sure if it’s the engrossing images, the way the sentences are split up on the pages, or the way the poem sounds on my tongue, but whatever the case Morstad’s The Swing is definitely doing something right. Evocative and mesmerizing all at once, this is one book that is sure to engage kids right from the get-go. With its new packaging, Stevenson’s classic feels as fresh and new as anything you’ll find on your bookstore and library shelves today. Beautiful. There’s no other word for it.
On shelves October 20th.
Source: Final copy sent from publisher for review.
Like This? Then Try:
- A Child’s Garden of Verses by Robert Louis Stevenson, illustrated by Tasha Tudor
- Higher Higher by Leslie Patricelli
- Follow Me by Tricia Tusa
Video:
And here is the rather lovely book trailer for this rather lovely book.
Filed under: Best Books of 2012, Reviews
About Betsy Bird
Betsy Bird is currently the Collection Development Manager of the Evanston Public Library system and a former Materials Specialist for New York Public Library. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of EPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
How to Do Just About Everything in 2022
31 Days, 31 Lists: 2022 Great Board Books
Romantic Killer, vol. 1 | Review
Post-It Note Reviews: Quick peeks at 8 new titles
The Classroom Bookshelf is Moving
ADVERTISEMENT
Thank you. I hope MY 1 year old will agree with yours!
I can’t way to see this book! My grandmother read Robert Louis Stevenson aloud to me all the time when I was little. I too hear her voice when I’ve read his poems to my girls. How great it will be to have this poem in board back format.
The little white-haired girl is impossibly fetching, isn’t she? It’s nice to see Simply Read moving into board books – I remember how important they were to us when my own boys were small and what a treat it was to find something beautiful instead of just cute or funny (not that cute and funny don’t have their place). The Cozy Classics they are doing now look pretty wonderful too.
Also, on the topic of RLS, there is a wonderful audio version of Child’s Garden of Verse set to music that both my boys had on repeat for a good few years. Will try to remember the name of the artist.
Found it! He’s since released another one which includes The Swing but I think my very favourite was Bed in Summer.
You can listen to samples here:
http://houseatthecorner.com/music_listen.html
This is a beautiful book and thoughtful review, but what’s with the dismissive detour/rant re: artists who sell their work on Etsy?
It comes rather out of the blue, especially because Julie Morstad’s art here obviously harkens to Mary Blair and mid-century illustration, rather than some notion of a single Etsy in-house illustration style.
Etsy is just a shopfront and selling platform, and there are many good illustrators, (fledgeling and professional) working in different mediums, methods, and with different sensibilities who use it to sell their work. I sell my work there, and many of my friends and peers do, all with totally different illustration styles. Established picture book illustrators, like Calef Brown and Sophie Blackall use it as well. Dismissing or casting suspicion on artists because they use a certain online shopfront is a bit baby-with-the-bathwater, don’t you think?
You wouldn’t declare thousands of drivers suspect just because they take the same model of car to work. Etsy is just a vehicle, and it’s the drivers (good, bad, or otherwise) who matter.
I agree of course, but you must admit that for every Calef Brown and Sophie Blackall there is an artist who represents a kind of Etsy-esthetic. The best way I can describe it is to refer you to the Portlandia episode where they “put a bird on it”. Which is to say, to make something interesting they just slap the silhouette of a bird on that object. Go through Etsy and you’ll see lots of art that does simply that. There are great illustrators and artists on Etsy, no question, but when I mention it in the context of the review I’m referring not to the Etsy that highlights the creative (and believe me when I say that for editors it’s the shopping ground of future picture book illustrators) but to the Etsy that produces a single unified look that we are all very familiar with already. My whole point in this piece is an agreement with you that Morstad is indeed more like Mary Blair than, as you put it so well “a single Etsy in-house illustration style”. Besides which, I think I made it clear that my initial Etsy suspicions were ill-founded.
“sniff ‘Etsy'”?
Wow, that’s a little harsh. I’m not sure what Etsy has to with this book at all, perhaps you are referencing a retro 60s feel? And while we’re on the subject of similar artist’s style, if I had to say this book looks like any particular artist, I’d have to say it harks back to Gyo Fujikawa’s style and layout for books. Good thing the 60s, Mary Blair, and Fujikawa were born before Etsy; according to some, they never would’ve made it.