Review of the Day: Genies, Meanies, and Magic Rings (Part Two)

Illustrators often end up with the short end of the stick when it comes to critiquing the books they work upon.  Because I had read (and greatly enjoyed) the Stephen Mitchell book of poetry for children, “The Wishing Bone”, I had seen Mr. Tom Pohrt’s work before.  His images aren’t flashy or pompous.  They’re small subtle complements to the action.  Maybe two figures will relax in one image and in another a woman will scold.  It would be easy enough to slip into Arab stereotyping in this kind of book, but Pohrt has the matter well in hand, and every character is a unique individual.  If Mitchell makes the book worth reading then Pohrt makes it worth viewing.

The matter of race takes a funny turn in these books. I don’t know how necessary it would have been to mention that the villain in Aladdin was, “a tall dark-skinned man with a long nose.”  I might also be interested in looking up the original text to see if this description was always the case (turban and all).  Also, the genie is described as a white dude (my words, not his) with golden hair and a beard, as featured on the cover of this book.  An interesting choice and one that I suspect might lead to a very interesting discussion of textual analysis and race in children’s interpretations of past fairy tales and fables.

On the whole, however, I can’t imagine any reasonable arguments against buying this title immediately if not sooner.  You already own an edition of these tales?  Uh huh.  And do the kids dig it?  Anyone looking for a text to combat Disney’s version of “Aladdin” would do well to grab this book for their shelves pronto.  Well-researched, well-written, well on its way to making a name for Mitchell and Pohrt.