Review of the Day: How the Sphinx Got to the Museum by Jessie Hartland
One of the most frequent requests I get from parents in my library is a desire for books on “community workers”. Which is to say, their children have been given an assignment in school on writing about the people who work in their neighborhood, and so we are charged with coming up with books about sanitation workers, doctors, bus drivers, etc. This being New York City, I always kind of wish that I’d get a request for a community worker a little out of the ordinary. How about a request for a book on a conservator? Or a museum registrar? Why do docents always end up with the short end of the stick? Of course, even if I did get a request for one of these, I’d actually have to produce a book that says what such museum folks actually do. Still, that’s no problem since the publication of How the Sphinx Got to the Museum. Basically author/illustrator Jessie Hartland came up with a radical notion. Why not combine a book that explains the jobs people do with a real life mystery (how a busted sphinx was returned to its full splendor for display in the Metropolitan Museum of Art) and then present it in a cumulative tale format? Why that’s so crazy it just might work. And work it does in a story that satisfies a child’s need for story while also working in some pretty cool details about why museums are full of statues from other countries far far away.
A group of kids visit The Metropolitan Museum of Art and are told a strange fact. Before their eyes sits a sphinx created for the Pharaoh Hatshepsut. The kicker? That same statue was destroyed a mere twenty years after its creation on orders from Hatshepsut’s successor and stepson. So how on earth has it come to reside fully intact in a museum in America? To answer that you have to begin at the beginning. And so the docent recounts the many steps and people who contributed to the sphinx’s story. Hatshepsut commissioned, the sculptors sculpted, the priests admired it, and the stepson had it destroyed. From there the story takes a turn, rediscovered centuries later in a pit by an archaeologist, brought to America, and restored. As each piece of the puzzle falls into place we are consistently reminded of the people who came before, until at long last we reach the present day. A section called “More History” at the end clarifies many of the details and gives kids additional information on the real statue and its current location.
The real trick here, as it is with any cumulative tale, is to know how to tell a story with a lot of repetition without making it boring. I should clarify what a cumulative tale is by this point, yes? Basically what I’m talking about is a book that tells a story the same way you would in a classic like This is the House that Jack Built. It’s where you introduce an element and then build on it, always returning for a kind of chorus. The books that are successful at this (like The Apple Pie That Papa Baked) know how to keep a reader interested, even as the same information is conjured up time and time again. In the case of How the Sphinx Got to the Museum, Hartland has the advantage of telling a true story. As a result, the more you repeat what happened to the sphinx (it was . . . “secured by the Art Movers, supervised by the Department of Antiquities, found in a pit by the Archaeologist”) not only are you bringing up the true story of its travels, you’re also teaching kids about certain jobs by having them repeat the wordy occupations over and over again. Teachable moments! Woot!
The fact that the book is mostly factual places it in a funny position in libraries. Where do you put it? It kind of looks like a picture book, and indeed might be interesting there, but in the end it tends to end up in the Ancient Egypt section of nonfiction. Interesting since there are some details that were stretched a bit to fit the telling. At the end of the book Hartland admits freely that “The part of this book when Hatshepsut orders several statues from the sculptor is somewhat made up.” I trust her as an author, but when I read that I kind of want to know how many other details were true. Did the Sphinx really get sent to America on a ship called The Cingalese Prince? I mean, it had to, right? Who would make that kind of thing up? A little Bibliography or section at the end recommending websites or books for further reading would not have been out of place here. I liked the “More History” but found myself wanting more for the interested kids out there.
Hartland has a bit of a Maira Kalman style about her. That incredibly flat, near two-dimensional quality of her art. The book offers no hints on her style or what medium she uses, and her website is equally mum on the subject. What’s kind of cool is that she has in her short picture book career already created books for Candlewick, Penguin, Chronicle, Bloomsbury, and now Big Apple Books. In the case of this particular book, Hartland has chosen to set many of the images here against relatively uncluttered backgrounds. There’s always adequate room for her text, which doesn’t sound impressive until you realize how long the cumulative collection of folks involved with the statue really are. After a while, you also begin to notice that each person’s designation (“Department of Antiquities”, “Egyptian Priests”, etc.) is granted its own distinctive font. That’s a detail that keeps the book visually stimulating, even if you don’t notice it right off the bat.
Of course the best news to leave you with is the fact that this is not Hartland’s sole journey into this kind of nonfiction cumulative fare. Following up this title will be a similar book about how a dinosaur got to what I believe will be The Smithsonian, as well as a third title about how a painting (to be determined) got from artist to permanent gallery display. Clearly this is a fun concept with a lot of different applications one can work with and the first in the series is a true keeper. If you, like myself, are a bit sick of the endless identical Ancient Egypt children’s fare out there and would like to see something original, Hartland has your number. Consider this a great way to bridge the past and the present for your kids.
On shelves now.
Source: Borrowed copy from library for review.
Filed under: Reviews
About Betsy Bird
Betsy Bird is currently the Collection Development Manager of the Evanston Public Library system and a former Materials Specialist for New York Public Library. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of EPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.
SLJ Blog Network